✝ Catholic Treasury Network
account_balance The Church

How Can the Church Call Herself Holy After the Abuse Crisis?

Priests abused children, and bishops covered it up. For many people that ends the conversation. The question deserves an answer that neither minimises the evil nor confuses the Church with the sins of her members.

menu_book Treated in full under Ecclesiology

The Objection

The Claim

The Church claims to be holy, to be guided by the Holy Spirit, and to teach the world about morality. Yet in country after country, inquiries have found that priests sexually abused children, and that bishops moved offenders from parish to parish and silenced victims to protect the institution’s reputation. An organisation that did that has no moral authority. To keep calling it “holy” is to add insult to injury.

This objection comes from real wounds, and it must be answered with that in mind. Any answer that begins by defending the institution before it has faced what was done has already failed. In Australia, the Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse (2013–2017) documented the scale of what happened in Catholic institutions in painful detail, as inquiries in Ireland, the United States, Germany, France and elsewhere did for their countries.

Facing What Happened

Two distinct evils are involved. The first is the abuse itself, committed by men ordained to act in the person of Christ. The second, in some ways more damning for the Church as an institution, is the response of many bishops and superiors: disbelieving victims, moving abusers to new assignments, treating crimes as matters for private discipline, and putting the avoidance of scandal ahead of the safety of children.

Christ’s own words on this are the most severe in the Gospels: whoever causes one of these little ones who believe in him to sin, it would be better for him to have a great millstone fastened round his neck and to be drowned in the depth of the sea (Matthew 18:6). The Church’s teaching does not soften that sentence. It condemns these acts and their concealment entirely.

What “Holy” Has Always Meant

When the Creed calls the Church holy, it has never meant that her members, or even her clergy, are free from sin. The Church has always taught the opposite. Lumen Gentium (no. 8) says that the Church, embracing sinners in her bosom, is at the same time holy and always in need of being purified, and so she follows constantly the path of penance and renewal. The Catechism says the same (CCC 827).

The Church is holy because of her source and her gifts, not because of her members’ record. She is holy because Christ, her head, is holy, and gave himself up for her to sanctify her (Ephesians 5:25–26). She is holy because the sacraments, the Scriptures and the faith she hands on are holy, and because the Holy Spirit dwells in her. And she is holy in her saints, in whom that holiness bears fruit. All of these are entrusted to sinful people.

This was settled in the early Church against the Donatists, who held that sacraments administered by unworthy clergy were invalid, and that a Church containing such men could not be the true Church. Augustine answered that the holiness of the sacraments comes from Christ, not from the minister, and that the Church on earth is a field in which wheat and weeds grow together until the harvest (Matthew 13:24–30).

No Excuse

None of this is an excuse. The distinction between the Church’s holiness and her members’ sins cannot be used to shield those members from judgment. If anything, it makes the sins graver. The abusers betrayed the very holiness they were ordained to serve, and those who covered up their crimes betrayed both the victims and the Church. Judas was one of the Twelve, chosen by Christ himself. His betrayal did not make Christ’s mission false; it showed what a chosen man can do.

The Church’s response has, slowly and too late in many places, begun to change. Rules for reporting and safeguarding are now in place in many countries. In 2019 Pope Francis dismissed the former cardinal Theodore McCarrick from the clerical state, and issued Vos Estis Lux Mundi, setting out procedures for reporting abuse and holding bishops to account for cover-ups; it was made permanent in 2023. Whether these measures are enough is a fair question, and survivors are right to keep asking it.

The Distinction

The Church is holy in her head, Christ, in the sacraments and faith she has received, and in her saints. She is not holy in the sense of being free from sinners, including sinful clergy and bishops. That distinction explains how she can still confess her holiness. It does not excuse, and must never be used to excuse, what was done.

Common Replies

”Doesn’t this distinction let the institution off the hook?”

It would, if it were used to deflect attention from the abuse or the cover-up. It must not be. The Church’s own teaching says she is always in need of purification and penance, and that is a call to repentance, not to self-defence. Holiness that belongs to Christ does not belong to bishops who failed to protect children.

”Why would anyone stay in a Church like this?”

Many people have left, and their anger is understandable. Those who stay usually do so not because they trust the institution’s managers, but because they believe that Christ is truly present in the sacraments and that the faith is true. Peter, who denied Christ three times, put it this way when others were leaving: “Lord, to whom shall we go? You have the words of eternal life” (John 6:68). Staying is not the same as approving.

”Isn’t abuse more common in the Church because of celibacy?”

Studies of abuse in institutions have found that it occurs across many settings, including among married clergy of other denominations, teachers, sports coaches and family members. The causes inquiries have identified in Catholic settings include clericalism, poor screening and formation, secrecy, and a culture that put the Church’s reputation above children’s safety. Those are failures the Church has to correct, whatever one thinks about celibacy.

arrow_back All challenges