Questions actually put to the faith — by sceptics, by students, and by Catholics themselves. Each is stated at full strength before it is answered, and points back to the tract where the doctrine is treated in full.
Whether God can be known by reason, whether he has spoken, and what it means to hold something on faith rather than on evidence.
The Big Bang, quantum vacuum fluctuations, and multiverse theory are often said to have retired Aquinas's argument from causality. The argument being retired usually isn't the one Aquinas actually made.
Read the answerThe Church teaches that God's existence can be known with certainty by natural reason, apart from revelation. That is a bolder claim than most critics expect — and a more limited one than some believers assume.
Read the answerA good God would prevent evil; an all-powerful God could; evil exists. The Catholic answer rests on what evil is, why God permits what he does not cause, and the claim that God brings a greater good out of evil. It does not claim that we can see that good in every case.
Read the answerThe Trinity is often dismissed as a contradiction. The doctrine actually affirms one divine nature and three Persons, distinguished only by their relations of origin — a mystery reason cannot prove, but can show is not absurd.
Read the answerWhere the doctrine of creation and the findings of the natural sciences actually meet, and where they are answering different questions.
The Church has no quarrel with evolutionary biology as such — and Laudato Si' has drawn fire from both sides of the environmental debate for saying so with consequences attached.
Read the answerPopulation genetics suggests modern humans descend from a population numbering thousands, not a single pair. Catholic theologians have proposed serious ways of holding a historical Adam and Eve alongside the science. None is official, and the question is still open.
Read the answerDavid Hume argued that a miracle breaks the laws of nature and that testimony can never outweigh our experience of those laws. The Catholic account defines a miracle differently, and Hume's argument assumes what it sets out to prove.
Read the answerWhere Catholic teaching comes from, how it is transmitted, and what is happening when it appears to change.
The apparent reversals are real cases that need answering. The distinction the tradition draws is between a doctrine unfolding what it always contained and a doctrine being contradicted — and it is a distinction with teeth.
Read the answerIn 2018, the Catechism began calling the death penalty 'inadmissible.' Whether that's a legitimate development of doctrine or a genuine reversal is one of the sharpest live disputes in Catholic moral theology today.
Read the answerSceptics list discrepancies between the Gospels as proof that Scripture is unreliable. The Church has known about them since the Fathers. Her teaching on inspiration, literary form and the historicity of the Gospels explains why differences in detail do not amount to error.
Read the answerThe person of Christ, the historical evidence for him, and how one death two thousand years ago bears on anyone now.
Mythicism gets outsized attention online. Mainstream secular scholarship — including its most skeptical voices — treats Jesus's existence as one of the least contested facts in ancient history.
Read the answerA popular argument holds that Jesus' divinity was a later development, found only in John's Gospel. In fact the earliest Gospels and the earliest letters show Jesus acting and speaking in ways that only make sense as a claim to divine authority.
Read the answerCritics call the Cross 'divine child abuse': an angry Father punishing an innocent Son. Catholic teaching says something quite different. God did not need the Cross in order to forgive, and what saves us is not the quantity of Christ's suffering but the love and obedience with which he offered it.
Read the answerAuthority, infallibility, and the visible institution measured against the claims made for it.
The synodal process has revived a very old question in a new form: how far does the Church's structure of authority actually extend, and what, precisely, is it capable of changing?
Read the answerExtra Ecclesiam nulla salus has been taught for centuries, sometimes in very severe language. Modern teaching affirms it and also teaches that those who are inculpably ignorant of the Church can be saved. The two are not a contradiction, and the Church has rejected both the rigorist and the indifferentist readings.
Read the answerThe sexual abuse of minors by clergy, and its concealment by those in authority, is among the gravest scandals in the Church's history. How the Church can still confess that she is holy depends on what that confession has always meant, and it is no excuse for what was done.
Read the answerWhat the sacraments do, why matter is involved at all, and the difference between a sign and a cause.
During COVID, millions of Catholics watched Mass on a screen instead of attending in person. Whether that ever fulfilled the Sunday obligation turns on a distinction most livestreams never explained.
Read the answerCritics argue that chemistry shows the host remains bread, and that 'substance' is a discredited piece of Aristotelian physics. Transubstantiation actually claims that everything a scientist can measure remains unchanged, and that what changes is not the kind of thing physics measures.
Read the answerIn 1994 John Paul II declared that the Church has no authority to ordain women as priests, and that this is to be held definitively. The reasoning rests on Christ's own choice, the Church's constant practice, and the meaning of the priesthood as a sign of Christ the Bridegroom. It makes no claim that women are inferior.
Read the answerPredestination, merit, and the long argument about how divine causality and human liberty occupy the same act.
The Church has never resolved how grace and free will fit together — but she has been unambiguous that grace is never a wage owed for enough faith or effort, which is exactly what the prosperity gospel gets wrong.
Read the answerOriginal sin is often understood as being punished for another person's crime, which would indeed be unjust. Catholic teaching describes it differently: not a personal guilt we committed, but the loss of a gift we would otherwise have inherited.
Read the answerThe Catholic Church is often said to teach salvation by good works. The Council of Trent taught that no one can merit the grace of justification, and that good works are themselves the fruit of grace. Real differences with Protestant teaching remain, but they are not the ones usually supposed.
Read the answerConscience, intention, and hard cases — where the tradition draws its distinctions and why they are not evasions.
Both technologies promise real goods — a child for an infertile couple, a cure for an inherited disease. The Church's objections aren't to the goods themselves, but to specific means she judges incompatible with human dignity.
Read the answerMany people assume motive and outcome are what make an action right. Catholic teaching holds that some acts are wrong whatever the intention, while intention and circumstances still shape how good or bad an act is and how guilty the person who does it.
Read the answerCritics say that natural family planning and contraception have the same goal, so the Church cannot consistently forbid one and permit the other. Catholic teaching answers that morality depends on what one chooses to do, not only on one's goal, and that abstaining from intercourse differs morally from sterilising it.
Read the answerWhat prayer is for, how the interior life is ordered, and what separates Christian contemplation from practices that resemble it.
Silent sitting, attention to the breath, a quiet mind — Catholic contemplative prayer and secular mindfulness can look identical from the outside. What actually distinguishes them isn't technique but what the practice is for.
Read the answerIf God is all-knowing and his will cannot change, prayer seems pointless: it cannot tell him anything or change his mind. The tradition answers that prayer was never meant to do either. God has willed to give some things through our asking, and prayer is how he draws us into his own work.
Read the answerMany people assume that approved apparitions are articles of Catholic faith, or that the Church simply endorses every reported vision. In fact private revelations add nothing to the deposit of faith, even approved ones never require belief, and the Church judges them with considerable caution.
Read the answerDeath, judgement, and how eternal loss can be reconciled with an infinitely merciful God.
Von Balthasar's famous question split Catholic theology between those who see it as a legitimate hope and those who see it as a dangerous softening of a hard truth Scripture and tradition insist on.
Read the answerReports of tunnels of light and encounters with deceased relatives are often taken as vindicating an afterlife in general. Whether they vindicate the specifically Catholic account of death and judgment is a much narrower question.
Read the answerMany people find the doctrine of hell incompatible with God's love: no finite sin could deserve endless suffering. Catholic teaching understands hell not as a torment imposed on the unwilling, but as the final, freely chosen exclusion of oneself from God, made permanent by death.
Read the answer