If Contraception Is Wrong, Why Is Natural Family Planning Allowed?
Both are ways of avoiding pregnancy. To many people, the Church's distinction looks like hair-splitting. It turns on the difference between declining to act and acting against what an act is.
The Objection
A couple using natural family planning (NFP) and a couple using the pill want exactly the same thing: sex without a baby. The first couple simply uses a calendar and a thermometer instead of a chemical. If the goal is the same, the moral character must be the same. Either both are wrong or neither is. The Church’s distinction is a technicality.
This is probably the most common objection to Catholic teaching on contraception, and it is a fair one to raise. The Church takes it seriously, and in fact answered it directly in Humanae Vitae (1968).
What the Church Teaches
Paul VI taught in Humanae Vitae that each and every marital act must remain open to the transmission of life (no. 11). He grounded this in the inseparable connection, willed by God, between the two meanings of the marital act, the unitive and the procreative, which the couple may not deliberately break on their own initiative (no. 12).
The same encyclical says that married couples may have serious reasons to space births, arising from physical or psychological conditions or from external circumstances. In that case, it is licit for them to take account of the natural rhythms of fertility and to have intercourse only in the infertile periods (no. 16). Paul VI addressed the objection head-on: in the one case the couple make legitimate use of a natural disposition; in the other they impede the development of natural processes.
Same Goal, Different Act
The objection assumes that an act’s morality is determined by its goal. But Catholic moral theology holds that an act is judged by its object (what is actually chosen) as well as by intention and circumstances (see Can a Good Intention Justify an Act That Is Wrong in Itself?). Two acts with the same goal can differ morally because different things are chosen.
An example from outside sexual ethics makes this clear. Suppose I want to keep a friend’s secret. I can decline to answer when someone asks about it, or I can tell a lie. My goal is identical in both cases. But declining to speak is a different act from asserting something false, and that difference matters morally.
Couples who use NFP for serious reasons choose not to have intercourse at certain times. When they do have intercourse, they do nothing to it: they do not alter it or deprive it of its meaning. Couples who contracept choose to have intercourse and also to do something to make that act infertile. What is chosen is different, even though the goal is the same.
John Paul II developed this in Familiaris Consortio (1981, no. 32), describing the difference as both anthropological and moral. In NFP, the couple accept the whole truth of their bodies, including fertility, and discipline their desires in light of it. In contraception, they treat fertility as an obstacle to be technically eliminated.
NFP and contraception may share a goal, but they are different acts. Abstaining from intercourse during fertile times leaves every act of intercourse intact. Contraception makes an act of intercourse infertile by deliberate intervention. The Church judges the act chosen, not only the goal.
Common Replies
”So NFP is just Catholic contraception?”
It can be misused. The Church does not permit NFP for any reason a couple likes. Humanae Vitae speaks of serious reasons, and Pius XII had earlier said that using the infertile periods without such reasons, simply to avoid children, would be wrong. A couple can have a contraceptive attitude while using natural methods. The moral difference in the acts does not remove the need for honest discernment about motives.
”Isn’t this all about effectiveness?”
No. Modern methods of NFP are much more effective than the old calendar method, but the Church’s teaching does not depend on that. A perfectly effective natural method would still be different in kind from contraception, and an ineffective form of contraception would still be contraception.
”Paul VI’s own commission recommended changing the teaching.”
It did. A majority of the papal commission set up to study the question recommended that the Church permit contraception in some circumstances. Paul VI considered its report and declined to follow it, explaining in Humanae Vitae (no. 6) that the commission had not reached full agreement and that some of its conclusions departed from the Church’s constant teaching. A commission advises; it does not teach with the Church’s authority.
”Most Catholics ignore this teaching anyway.”
Many do, in many countries. But the number of people who follow a teaching does not settle whether it is true. Paul VI himself predicted that the teaching would not be easily accepted. Whether he was right about its consequences is a debate worth having. Whether it is true depends on the arguments, not on how popular it is.