✝ Catholic Treasury Network
menu_book Scripture & Tradition

Do the Gospels Contradict Each Other? Inspiration, Inerrancy and Historical Criticism

One angel at the tomb or two? Two genealogies that disagree? The differences are real. What they show depends on what kind of books the Gospels are and what the Church means by inerrancy.

menu_book Treated in full under Christology

The Objection

The Claim

The Gospels disagree with each other. Matthew has one angel at the empty tomb, Luke has two men. Matthew and Luke give different genealogies for Jesus. John puts the cleansing of the Temple at the start of Jesus’ ministry, the others at the end. John seems to date the crucifixion differently in relation to the Passover. If the Bible is inspired and free from error, it should not contradict itself. Since it does, it is neither.

None of these discrepancies is a modern discovery. Augustine wrote a whole treatise, On the Harmony of the Evangelists, around the year 400, because pagan critics were already raising them. The Church has never hidden from the differences. What she has done is ask what kind of books the Gospels are.

What the Church Teaches About Inspiration

The Second Vatican Council’s constitution on revelation, Dei Verbum (1965), teaches that God is the author of Scripture and that he made use of human authors, who wrote as true authors, with their own abilities and styles (no. 11). Because God is the principal author, the books teach firmly, faithfully and without error the truth God wanted put into them for the sake of our salvation.

The same document instructs readers to attend to literary forms (no. 12). Truth is expressed differently in history, poetry, prophecy and other kinds of writing, and in the customary ways ancient people narrated and reported. To find what the sacred author meant to assert, one has to read his work as the kind of writing it is, by the standards of its own time.

That principle was not invented in 1965. Leo XIII’s Providentissimus Deus (1893) and Pius XII’s Divino Afflante Spiritu (1943) both developed it, and both insisted on inerrancy at the same time.

What Kind of Books Are the Gospels?

Dei Verbum (no. 19) affirms without hesitation that the four Gospels are historical, and that they faithfully hand on what Jesus really did and taught. It also describes how they were written. The evangelists selected some things from the many that had been handed on, summarised others, and explained others with an eye to the needs of the churches they wrote for. They did this, the Council says, in such a way that they always told us the honest truth about Jesus.

In other words, the Gospels are not transcripts or police reports. They are four portraits of the same person, drawn from the apostolic preaching, each arranged for a purpose. Ancient biography routinely arranged material by theme rather than strict chronology, condensed events, and paraphrased speech. By the standards their first readers knew, doing so was not error.

The Cases Themselves

The angels at the tomb. Matthew mentions one angel (28:2–5); Luke speaks of two men in dazzling clothes (24:4). An account that mentions one speaker does not deny that a second was present. Witnesses to the same event regularly report it this way, and courts treat exact verbal agreement between witnesses as a sign of collusion, not of truth.

The genealogies. Matthew’s list (1:1–17) is arranged in three sets of fourteen generations and traces the royal line through Solomon. Luke’s (3:23–38) runs back to Adam through Nathan. Explanations go back to the early Church. Julius Africanus, writing in the third century, proposed that the two lines reflect legal and natural descent under the custom of levirate marriage. Many modern scholars suggest that one line is Mary’s. The lists are clearly composed for different purposes; neither claims to be the only possible account of Jesus’ ancestry.

The Temple and the Passover. John’s placement of the Temple cleansing and his dating of the Last Supper and crucifixion are genuinely difficult, and scholars still debate them. Some hold that John arranges events theologically; some that there were two cleansings; some that different Passover calendars were in use. A Catholic is free to weigh these explanations on their merits. What the Church denies is that any of them shows the evangelists asserting something false.

The Distinction

Inerrancy means Scripture does not err in what its authors truly assert. It does not mean that four evangelists must report the same event in the same words, order or level of detail. Differences in selection, arrangement and emphasis are features of the kind of books the Gospels are, not mistakes in them.

Common Replies

”Doesn’t ‘for the sake of our salvation’ mean only the religious parts are inerrant?”

Some scholars read Dei Verbum 11 that way. Others point out that Leo XIII, Benedict XV and Pius XII had all explicitly rejected limiting inerrancy to matters of faith and morals, and that the Council’s own notes cite those documents. On the second reading, the phrase describes the purpose for which Scripture was written, not a part of Scripture that is exempt from error. The question is still discussed, but the fuller reading has stronger support in the Church’s prior teaching.

”Historical criticism has shown the Gospels are late and unreliable.”

Historical criticism is a set of tools, and the Church encourages Catholic scholars to use it (Divino Afflante Spiritu; Pontifical Biblical Commission, 1964 and 1993). Its results vary widely. Many scholars date the Gospels within living memory of Jesus, and the historical core they preserve is broadly accepted even by sceptical historians (see Did Jesus Exist?). What the Church rejects is not the method but philosophical assumptions sometimes attached to it, such as the assumption that miracles cannot happen.

”Why didn’t God just give us one consistent Gospel?”

The Church in the second century considered exactly this. Tatian produced the Diatessaron, a single blended Gospel, and it was popular in some places. The Church kept the four instead. Four independent witnesses who agree on the substance and differ in detail are more credible than one, not less. That is how historians weigh testimony about any event.

arrow_back All challenges