Are Miracles Impossible? Hume, the Laws of Nature, and What a Miracle Actually Claims
Since Hume, educated opinion has treated miracles as violations of natural law that no testimony could ever establish. Both halves of that claim are weaker than they look.
The Objection
Science works because nature is uniform. A miracle would be a breach of the laws of nature, and every observation ever made confirms those laws. Against that mountain of evidence, a report that someone rose from the dead or was instantly healed can never weigh enough. It is always more likely that the witnesses were mistaken or lying than that nature was suspended. A rational person should therefore never believe a miracle report.
That, in outline, is David Hume’s argument in Section X of his Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding (1748). It has shaped modern assumptions so thoroughly that many people take it for a scientific finding. It is in fact a philosophical argument, and it can be examined like one.
What a Miracle Is
Hume defines a miracle as a violation of the laws of nature. Aquinas defines it differently. A miracle is something done by God outside the order of nature as a whole, something no created power could bring about (Summa Theologiae I, q. 105, a. 7; Summa contra Gentiles III, 101).
The difference matters. On the classical view, the laws of nature describe how created things behave by their own natures when nothing else acts on them. Water flows downhill; bodies decay after death. A miracle does not make water stop being water or show that the description was wrong. It is an effect produced directly by the first cause, God, without the created causes that would normally be needed.
An illustration often used is this. If you put a hundred dollars in a drawer on Monday and add another hundred on Tuesday, the laws of arithmetic say you should find two hundred on Wednesday. If you find fifty, the laws of arithmetic have not been broken; a thief has intervened. The laws tell you what happens if nothing interferes. They cannot tell you whether something has. Whether God ever acts directly in the world is a question about God, not about physics.
Is a Miracle Impossible?
If God exists and created the natural order, there can be no principled reason he could not act within it, any more than an author cannot write a new chapter. The First Vatican Council (Dei Filius, 1870) taught that miracles are possible, that they can be known with certainty, and that they are among the clearest signs that a revelation is from God. Miracles, on this view, are not a gap in nature to be explained away. They are signs given within a world God already holds in being.
So the real question is not whether science rules miracles out. It cannot. The question is whether God exists, and whether there is good evidence that he has acted in a particular case.
Hume’s Argument Examined
Hume says our experience of nature’s uniformity is “firm and unalterable”, and that against it testimony to a miracle always fails. But experience is uniform against miracles only if every report of a miracle is false. That is precisely the question being argued. If even one such report were true, experience would not be uniform. The argument assumes its conclusion.
Hume’s principle also proves too much. It would forbid us to believe any genuinely unprecedented event, however well attested, simply because it was unprecedented. Scientists themselves do not reason that way about novel observations. They ask whether the evidence is good.
Hume makes a fair point when he warns that people are credulous, that wonder makes them less careful, and that religious claims attract fraud. The Church agrees, which is why she investigates claimed miracles with considerable scepticism.
A miracle is not a broken law of nature but an effect produced by God without the natural causes that would normally be needed. Whether miracles happen depends on whether God exists and on the evidence in particular cases. It cannot be decided in advance by defining miracles as impossible.
Common Replies
”Isn’t ‘God did it’ just a science-stopper?”
Not when it is reached at the end of an investigation rather than at the start. When the Church examines a claimed healing at Lourdes or for a canonisation, the medical panels look for every natural explanation first. Most claimed cures are not accepted. Only around seventy Lourdes healings have been officially recognised as miraculous in more than a century and a half, out of many thousands reported. That is the opposite of credulity.
”Every past miracle claim has turned out to have a natural explanation.”
Many have, and the Church has often been the one to show it. But the claim that every case has been explained is just Hume’s assumption again. A fair-minded enquirer has to look at the strongest cases individually, not dismiss them all by rule.
”Why would God need to interrupt his own creation?”
He does not need to. A miracle is not God repairing a faulty machine; it is a sign, given freely, that points beyond nature to its author. The Resurrection of Christ, the miracle on which Christianity stands or falls (1 Corinthians 15:14), is not a correction to the order of nature. It is the beginning of its renewal.
”If God can act directly, why doesn’t he do it all the time?”
Because a world in which God constantly overrode the natures he made would be a world without stable natures, and therefore without science, human responsibility, or the reliable order that makes life possible. The rarity of miracles is part of what lets them function as signs.