If God Already Knows What We Need, Why Pray?
Jesus himself said the Father knows what we need before we ask. Then, in the next breath, he taught his disciples how to ask.
The Objection
God knows everything, including what we need and what we will ask. His will is eternal and does not change. So prayer cannot inform him of anything, and it cannot persuade him to do what he had not already decided. Either he was going to give us what we ask for anyway, in which case prayer is unnecessary, or he was not, in which case prayer is useless. At best, prayer is a psychological exercise that makes the person praying feel better.
This puzzle is not a modern invention. Jesus himself raises it, telling his disciples not to heap up empty phrases like the pagans, who think they will be heard for their many words, because “your Father knows what you need before you ask him” (Matthew 6:8). What he says next is the key to the answer: “Pray then like this: Our Father who art in heaven…” (Matthew 6:9).
What Prayer Is Not For
The tradition agrees with the first half of the objection. Prayer does not inform God of anything. And prayer does not change God’s will, which is eternal and unchanging. Aquinas says plainly that we do not pray in order to change the divine plan (Summa Theologiae II-II, q. 83, a. 2).
If prayer is thought of as a way of getting a reluctant God to do what we want, the objection succeeds. But that is not the Christian understanding of prayer, and Christ explicitly rejects it.
What Prayer Is For
Aquinas’s answer is that God’s providence arranges not only what will happen, but by what causes it will happen. God brings about many effects through created causes: crops grow through rain and the farmer’s labour; children are born through their parents. He could produce these effects directly, but he chooses to give his creatures the dignity of being real causes.
Prayer is one of those causes. God has willed from eternity to give certain things through our asking for them. So we pray, Aquinas says, in order to obtain what God has planned to give in answer to prayer. He quotes Gregory the Great: by asking, people may merit to receive what almighty God planned before all ages to give them.
Seen this way, the dilemma disappears. It is not that God was going to give us something anyway, regardless of prayer, or would refuse it regardless of prayer. God eternally willed to give it because we would ask. Our prayer is part of his plan, not an attempt to interfere with it. Pascal made a similar point: God instituted prayer to give his creatures the dignity of causality.
What Prayer Does to Us
Prayer also changes the one who prays, though not only in a psychological sense. The Catechism describes prayer as a covenant relationship and a communion between God and the human person (CCC 2562–2565). In asking, we acknowledge that we depend on God for everything. We learn to want what he wants. Our desires are purified and enlarged so that we can receive what he wants to give. Augustine wrote that God does not need to be told what we want, but wants our desire to be exercised in prayer, so that we may be able to receive what he is preparing to give.
None of this makes petition a mere exercise in self-improvement. When Christians pray for a sick friend or for peace, they are really asking God for something, and he really hears them. The change in the one who prays comes with the answer; it does not replace it.
Prayer does not inform God or change his mind. God has willed from eternity to give some things through our asking, so our prayer is a real cause within his providence, not an attempt to override it. And in praying we are formed into people able to receive what he gives.
Common Replies
”Then why do so many prayers seem unanswered?”
The Catechism takes up this question frankly (CCC 2735–2737). Sometimes we ask for something that would not truly be good for us, or ask wrongly (James 4:3). Sometimes God’s answer is delayed, so that our desire may grow. Sometimes the answer is given in a form we do not recognise. Christ himself prayed in Gethsemane that the cup might pass from him, and added “not my will, but yours, be done” (Luke 22:42). The cup did not pass; the Resurrection followed. The model of Christian prayer is not a demand, but trust.
”Doesn’t this make God’s plan depend on us?”
In one sense yes, and that is the point. God has chosen to make his creatures real partners in his work, not puppets. But that does not make his plan uncertain to him. God knows from eternity what we will ask, and his providence includes our free prayers. Our freedom and his providence are not rivals (see Predestination, Free Will, and Why the Prosperity Gospel Gets Grace Backwards).
”Why pray for others? Can’t God help them without me?”
He can, but he wills to involve us in one another’s salvation, as members of one body. That is why Christians have always prayed for each other and asked the saints to pray for them. Intercession is not a way of reminding God of people he has forgotten. It is a way of loving them in the way God loves them.