Why Can't Women Be Priests? Ordinatio Sacerdotalis and the Question of Authority
To many people it looks like simple discrimination. The Church's answer is not that women are less worthy but that she has no authority to change what Christ did.
The Objection
Women are equal to men in dignity and ability. They lead nations, run companies and serve as clergy in other Christian communities. The Catholic Church’s refusal to ordain them reflects the patriarchal culture of first-century Palestine, not the will of God. Jesus chose male apostles because that was what his society expected. Keeping that practice today is discrimination dressed up as theology.
The objection deserves a direct answer. Many sincere Catholics feel its force, and the Church’s teaching is often presented badly, as if it rested on a claim that women are less capable or less holy. It does not.
What the Church Has Taught
In 1976 the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, with the approval of Paul VI, issued Inter Insigniores, setting out the Church’s reasons for not admitting women to priestly ordination. In 1994, in the apostolic letter Ordinatio Sacerdotalis, John Paul II declared that the Church has no authority whatsoever to confer priestly ordination on women, and that this judgment is to be definitively held by all the Church’s faithful.
A year later the Congregation, under Cardinal Ratzinger, answered a formal question about the status of that teaching. It said the teaching belongs to the deposit of faith and has been set forth infallibly by the ordinary and universal Magisterium. In 2018 Cardinal Ladaria, then Prefect of the same Congregation, reaffirmed that it is definitive.
Notice the form of the claim. The Church does not say she has decided not to ordain women. She says she lacks the authority to do so, because it is not hers to change.
Christ’s Choice
The first reason is what Christ did. He chose twelve men as apostles after a night of prayer (Luke 6:12–13). The apostles in turn chose men to succeed them. The Church in East and West has followed that practice without interruption for two thousand years.
Was Christ simply following the conventions of his day? Inter Insigniores points out that he broke those conventions freely and often where women were concerned. He spoke publicly with the Samaritan woman (John 4:27), to the surprise of his own disciples. He had women among his followers, who supported his ministry (Luke 8:1–3). He chose women as the first witnesses of his Resurrection, at a time when a woman’s testimony counted for little in court. And priestesses were common in the pagan religions of the surrounding world, so a female priesthood would not have been unthinkable. Christ did not choose men because he could not imagine anything else.
The Priest as Sign
The second reason concerns what the priesthood signifies. A sacrament is a sign that brings about what it signifies. At the altar, the priest acts in persona Christi, in the person of Christ, and above all in the Eucharist, where he speaks Christ’s own words: “This is my body.”
Scripture repeatedly describes God’s covenant with his people as a marriage, and presents Christ as the Bridegroom and the Church as his Bride (Ephesians 5:25–32; Revelation 19:7). Inter Insigniores (no. 5) argues that the priest, acting in the person of Christ the Bridegroom towards his Bride the Church, is a natural sign of that relationship as a man. Sexual difference is not a mere accident of the body; it is part of what the human person means. In the sacraments, as in the Incarnation itself, bodily signs matter.
The Church teaches that she has no authority to ordain women as priests, because she is bound by Christ’s choice and by the meaning of the priesthood as a sign of Christ the Bridegroom. The teaching concerns the nature of a sacrament, not the worth of women. Mary, the greatest of all creatures after Christ, was not an apostle.
Common Replies
”Isn’t this just like celibacy, a rule the Church could change?”
No. Clerical celibacy in the Latin Church is a discipline; married men are ordained in the Eastern Catholic Churches, and the rule could in principle be changed. The reservation of priestly ordination to men has been taught as something the Church cannot change, because it concerns the substance of the sacrament Christ instituted. That is the difference between a discipline and a doctrine.
”Was Ordinatio Sacerdotalis really infallible?”
The 1995 response from the Congregation said the teaching was infallibly taught by the ordinary and universal Magisterium, which John Paul II’s letter confirmed. Some theologians have questioned whether that classification is correct. But the question of which act made the teaching infallible does not change the Church’s position: the teaching is to be held definitively, and the popes since have reaffirmed it.
”What about women deacons?”
That is a separate question. The diaconate is a distinct order, and there is historical debate about what the deaconesses of the early Church did and whether they were ordained in the sacramental sense. Popes have set up commissions to study it. Ordinatio Sacerdotalis concerns priestly ordination specifically.
”Doesn’t this exclude women from leadership in the Church?”
It excludes them from the priesthood, not from holiness, teaching or influence. Four women are Doctors of the Church: Teresa of Avila, Catherine of Siena, Thérèse of Lisieux and Hildegard of Bingen. Founders of religious orders, martyrs, theologians and saints of every kind have been women. The Church’s greatest members are not her clergy but her saints, and greatness there is open to all.